_Q_ Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 For this opening day lineup Quinn-Tkachuk-Tuch Peterka-Thompson-Cousins Benson-McLeod-Zucker Aube Kubel-Lafferty-Malenstyn Dahlin-Power Byrum-Samuelsson Johnson-Clifton Pieces: Draft Picks Kulich Östlund Rosen Rousek Helenius Krebs Joker Greenway 1 1 Quote
Weave Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 Tkachuck is a center? We signed Cousins this offseason? Which multiverse are we in? 2 Quote
LGR4GM Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 37 minutes ago, _Q_ said: For this opening day lineup Quinn-Tkachuk-Tuch Peterka-Thompson-Cousins Benson-McLeod-Zucker Aube Kubel-Lafferty-Malenstyn Dahlin-Power Byrum-Samuelsson Johnson-Clifton Pieces: Draft Picks Kulich Östlund Rosen Rousek Helenius Krebs Joker Greenway You aren't getting Tkachuk for any combination of the pieces you list. You're parting with 1 of Quinn, Peterka, or Cozens. You're losing Samuelsson in that trade too. Peterka, Samuelsson, Rosen, and a pick is probably in the ballpark. Also Brady Tkachuk is a LW, not a center. 1 Quote
LGR4GM Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 Brady Tkachuk, 37g 37a, 74pts at 24yrs old in his 6th season. JJ Peterka, 28g 22a, 50pts at 22yrs old in his 2nd season. Tkachuk had 21g 23a for 44pts as a 21yr old in his second season. My point is, while I agree Tkachuk is better, is he so much better Buffalo should give up Peterka +++ for him. I'd be skeptical although, this year we'll know. 1 2 Quote
Doohicksie Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 22 minutes ago, Weave said: We signed Cousins this offseason? ...and suddenly he's a second liner, not a fourth liner that was bumped off the roster by Okposo? 1 Quote
TageMVP Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 34 minutes ago, Weave said: Tkachuck is a center? We signed Cousins this offseason? Which multiverse are we in? You called the topic starter out and then spelled Tkachuk wrong Lol 1 Quote
Doohicksie Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 21 minutes ago, TageMVP said: You called the topic starter out and then spelled Tkachuk wrong Lol Eh. 1 Quote
Weave Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 1 hour ago, TageMVP said: You called the topic starter out and then spelled Tkachuk wrong Lol And now you called me out! 3 Quote
Huckleberry Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 Players like that go out of the conference , can forget about this unless we pay more than we want to. Quote
Doohicksie Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 41 minutes ago, _Q_ said: I deserved to be called out! Quote
jad1 Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 3 hours ago, LGR4GM said: Brady Tkachuk, 37g 37a, 74pts at 24yrs old in his 6th season. JJ Peterka, 28g 22a, 50pts at 22yrs old in his 2nd season. Tkachuk had 21g 23a for 44pts as a 21yr old in his second season. My point is, while I agree Tkachuk is better, is he so much better Buffalo should give up Peterka +++ for him. I'd be skeptical although, this year we'll know. How about Byram, Benson, Östlund and next year's protected 1st. 1 1 1 Quote
LGR4GM Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 12 minutes ago, jad1 said: How about Byram, Benson, Östlund and next year's protected 1st. 1 2 Quote
Berg Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 (edited) 7 hours ago, LGR4GM said: You aren't getting Tkachuk for any combination of the pieces you list. You're parting with 1 of Quinn, Peterka, or Cozens. You're losing Samuelsson in that trade too. Peterka, Samuelsson, Rosen, and a pick is probably in the ballpark. Also Brady Tkachuk is a LW, not a center. Also KA is The same diplomat as my grandmother. So no chances Edited July 6 by Berg Quote
stinky finger Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 5 hours ago, LGR4GM said: You aren't getting Tkachuk for any combination of the pieces you list. You're parting with 1 of Quinn, Peterka, or Cozens. You're losing Samuelsson in that trade too. Peterka, Samuelsson, Rosen, and a pick is probably in the ballpark. Also Brady Tkachuk is a LW, not a center. If this is in the ballpark...... Quote
PerreaultForever Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 Since they got Ullmark I do not believe Ottawa is looking to trade Tkachuk at all. But, for the sake of saying it, IF we could get him AND sign him to an extension, then they can have ALL of those little prospects in Rochester. ALL of them. Rosen, Rousek, Kulich, Östlund and even the new guy Helenius. Because I just don't care about prospects any more. Especially little ones. 1 1 Quote
TageMVP Posted July 6 Report Posted July 6 56 minutes ago, PerreaultForever said: Since they got Ullmark I do not believe Ottawa is looking to trade Tkachuk at all. But, for the sake of saying it, IF we could get him AND sign him to an extension, then they can have ALL of those little prospects in Rochester. ALL of them. Rosen, Rousek, Kulich, Östlund and even the new guy Helenius. Because I just don't care about prospects any more. Especially little ones. Not sure exactly what I'd trade for Tkachuk but I would definitely include Quinn or Benson in there if got the trade done Quote
TRIP65 Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 10 hours ago, _Q_ said: For this opening day lineup Quinn-Tkachuk-Tuch Peterka-Thompson-Cousins Benson-McLeod-Zucker Aube Kubel-Lafferty-Malenstyn Dahlin-Power Byrum-Samuelsson Johnson-Clifton Pieces: Draft Picks Kulich Östlund Rosen Rousek Helenius Krebs Joker Greenway Not Helenius, the others we have no room for them for 1-2 years. Quote
RochesterExpat Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 We may as well do a “what would you give up for McDavid? thread. Best I can offer is a 2026 3rd. 1 Quote
TRIP65 Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 6 hours ago, jad1 said: How about Byram, Benson, Östlund and next year's protected 1st. No, we have Grit now to be paying all this for one guy. We need Byram more and Benson's upside we don't even know yet. He showed us moves that maybe more than Tkachuk could give. Prospects and Draft picks. Not players we already have in Top 6. The only one I would do is maybe Cozens but that would be a money issue for FL. Kulich, Ryan Johnson, Greenway, Krebs, 1 and 2nd pick next year Tuch Tage Peterka Quinn Cozens Tkachuk Benson McLeod Zucker Malenstyn Lafferty Aube-Kubel Dahlin Power Bo Byram Joki Samuelsson Clifton UPL Levi Extra's: Rousek, Rosen, Bryson, Quote
TRIP65 Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 4 hours ago, stinky finger said: If this is in the ballpark...... Yeah, no way!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sabres have Grit and 3-4 Potential 30+ Goal Scorers as is. Not giving FL 3 of them, STUPID Quote
GASabresIUFAN Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 Q, the Continuum called. Tkachuk is not available. 2 Quote
kas23 Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 7 hours ago, jad1 said: How about Byram, Benson, Östlund and next year's protected 1st. No way. They can pry Benson out of my cold, dead hands. Quote
GASabresIUFAN Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 A Tkachuk brother may not be available, but Necas, Zegras and Ehlers still are. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.