Buffalo's best weck

[Stoner]

A few years ago I got a good CTB beef on weck at a Noco convenience store in Buffalo. The horseradish especially was an experience. I had to be in town today and got another one (different Noco). Huge disappointment. The roll was small and somewhat pale. The beef was grisly. The horseradish dull.

I have to come back in a month. Any suggestions? There's nothing quite like a good beef on kummelweck.

[Taro T]

Schwabl's.

[...]

You should probably seek out a Speedway. The Valeros are okay but are better known for their dogs.

[Cheektorado]

Bailo's on Bailey Ave.  Oh, wait that burned down in the 70's.

[tom webster]

Just now, Cheektorado said:

Bailo's on Bailey Ave.  Oh, wait that burned down in the 70's.

Haven’t heard that name in awhile.

[Cheektorado]

Just now, tom webster said:

Haven’t heard that name in awhile.

I was wondering if anyone would remember that place.

It was a big treat to eat there on Sunday's for us.  Beef on Weck came with brown gravy instead of Au Jus.  The way it supposed to be!

[Thorner]

20 minutes ago, DarthEbriate said:

In my experience there's no such thing as luck.

 

2 minutes ago, tom webster said:

Haven’t heard that name in awhile.

A long time

 

 

a long time 

[Indabuff]

Apparently Bar-Bill has excellent beef on weck but it's sacrilege to go there and not order the wings.

[Taro T]

3 minutes ago, Indabuff said:

Apparently Bar-Bill has excellent beef on weck but it's sacrilege to go there and not order the wings.

You can get both.  Their Beef on Weck is very good.  Schwabl's is better.

[matter2003]

Charlie The Butcher

[tom webster]

8 minutes ago, Taro T said:

You can get both.  Their Beef on Weck is very good.  Schwabl's is better.

Swanning House isn’t bad, either.

[Porous Five Hole]

This might be cliche, but Bar Bill is legit. 

[inkman]

I definitely read this as Buffalo’s best week. I was wondering why it involved a sandwich, although Beef on Weck can certainly bring me much joy. 

[Eleven]

39 minutes ago, Taro T said:

Schwabl's.

I've been hearing and reading bad things recently--but mostly from people I don't know.  When were you last there?  

I don't love beef on weck so I don't have a nominee, sorry!

[Taro T]

Just now, Eleven said:

I've been hearing and reading bad things recently--but mostly from people I don't know.  When were you last there?  

I don't love beef on weck so I don't have a nominee, sorry!

Haven't been there in a while.  (But haven't been to the Bar-Bill in a long time either.)

[SwampD]

Kelly's Korner.

[WhenWillItEnd66]

The game last night,  wait,  I thought you said wreck

[Contempt]

Adrians on Grand Island is pretty good but idk if they are open for the season yet. I ate BarBill in January, it was pretty good.

[tom webster]

37 minutes ago, Cheektorado said:

I was wondering if anyone would remember that place.

It was a big treat to eat there on Sunday's for us.  Beef on Weck came with brown gravy instead of Au Jus.  The way it supposed to be!

Yep. One of my dad’s favorites. The family bakery was around the area.

[Kr632]

Bar Bill. Get some wings too. 

[Contempt]

1 minute ago, Kr632 said:

Bar Bill. Get some wings too. 

Yes. The wings were God tier.

[Cheektorado]

16 minutes ago, tom webster said:

Yep. One of my dad’s favorites. The family bakery was around the area.

My dad's favorite was Capolla's on Willaim St and N. Ogden.  Great Italian.

[Scottysabres]

At the House

[LGR4GM]

40 minutes ago, Eleven said:

I've been hearing and reading bad things recently--but mostly from people I don't know.  When were you last there?  

I don't love beef on weck so I don't have a nominee, sorry!

No love for Sidelines? Their's is solid and Bar-Bill is good too. 

[Eleven]

35 minutes ago, LGR4GM said:

No love for Sidelines? Their's is solid and Bar-Bill is good too. 

I just don't love beef on weck.  I'll eat it, sure, but I am hardly a connoisseur.