Leafs Lunch

[bunomatic]

This thread is like the land of the giants. 

Giant posts?

[Thorner]

5 hours ago, nfreeman said:

Settle down young fella.  I've watched the games just like (presumably) you have -- so I don't think anyone should start throwing around words like "dishonest" and "just glanced at the box scores."

As for what seems to be your core point -- you are right that since the original assertion related to "every time Jack has played the Leafs," it is correct to include the games from Jack's rookie year.  I don't expect that anyone would really be interested in debating whether Jack was best before Matthews arrived, but if one wants to be a stickler, there you go.

IMHO the real issue is whether Jack has been better than Matthews, which is how I interpreted the original assertion.  And while I agree that you unleashed a torrent of verbiage in support of your position, I don't think you "unequivocally" demonstrated anything other than an unwillingness to face the reality that Matthews has been better -- as he was again last night.

 

Jack has more goals and points head to head doesn’t he? 

Eichel - 13g, 9a, 22p 

Matthews - 11g, 6a, 17p

”face the reality” is pretty ham-handed 

Edited December 18, 2019 by Thorny

[nfreeman]

6 hours ago, Thorny said:

Jack has more goals and points head to head doesn’t he? 

Eichel - 13g, 9a, 22p 

Matthews - 11g, 6a, 17p

”face the reality” is pretty ham-handed 

What were the #s before this year — ie the period I was referring to, in multiple posts?

[LGR4GM]

8 hours ago, nfreeman said:

What were the #s before this year — ie the period I was referring to, in multiple posts?

You referred to it so you tell us.