Jump to content

Kane traded to San Jose for a Cond. ‘19 1st, Dan O’ Regan and Conditional 4th

Brawndo

By Brawndo
in The Aud Club

 Share

Recommended Posts

WildCard Hall of Famer

WildCard

Posted
Posted

$100 to your favorite charity if you can point out where I said "not to talk about it" in that sentence.

You said only GMs opinions matter in a thread where we are specifically sharing our opinion on something

Gramps Fourth Liner

Gramps

Posted
Posted

Ugh, what an absolutely terrible deal. Can we please just get a competent GM for once?

 

Listen to you guys ... you'd think you were in the room and heard GMJB turned down better offers. Guaranteed there were none.

Sabres Fan in NS Hall of Famer

Sabres Fan in NS

Posted
Posted

 

So, where are all the posts saying that this is better than having Kane walk for nothing in free agency?

 

I have to believe that this was the best deal to be made when it is very clear that Kane was / is not going sign with the Sabres come July 1st.

 

Hoping that he does, but I really don't think so.

WildCard Hall of Famer

WildCard

Posted
Posted

Listen to you guys ... you'd think you were in the room and heard GMJB turned down better offers. Guaranteed there were none.

There was no better offer over the last year than this?

SDS All Star

SDS

Posted
Posted

First, the way the trade was originally articulated was misleading.

 

It's a 2019 pick, not 2018.  It's a conditional second, not a conditional first.

 

This is just a bad deal.  Botterill was had.

 

What do you think happened then? Kane has been on the block for months. Do you think Botterill refused better offers? Do you think he didn't take that offer to other interested parties to beat? 

Ross Rhea Third Liner

Ross Rhea

Posted
Posted

Half the teams in the NHL probably don't want anything to do with him due to his attitude/reputation/off ice stuff whether its fair or not...when you are limiting the number of potential suitors you are also limiting his worth

Yup, he's not so over the top good that GMs would overlook Kanes baggage. His past rep matters a lot and it showed in the trade.

LTS First Liner

LTS

Posted
Posted

There was no better offer over the last year than this?

 

There is no evidence that a better offer ever existed.  There's speculation of course.

sabills Second Liner

sabills

Posted
Posted

The only way this turns into being palatable for me is one of 

 

1)Kane comes back on a decent deal to the Sabres this summer, which, though unlikely is still much more likely than

 

2)He resigns with the Sharks, the deal isn't lotto protected, and they miss the playoffs next year.

GASabresIUFAN All Star

GASabresIUFAN

Posted
Posted (edited)

This could go down as the worst trade in Sabres history. That 2nd rd pick in 2019 better turn out to be a great player.

 

How many more mediocre forwards do we need?

 

Just think of it this way, how bad were opinions of Kane around the league that this is the best we could do.

Edited by GASabresIUFAN
Sabre fan Third Liner

Sabre fan

Posted
Posted

I find it strange that nash and even hartman got much better returns...at least EXGMTM got 1si rounders for Vanek and Miller that were this year's...last thing we need is a 1st rounder next year. we have to wait like forever to see if the guy is any good at all we pick? very disappointing. I guess we should be enthused about the 4th round pick? Really? the whole trade now to Winnipeg is very one-sided with the jets having got a haul we got have...a guy in the AHL, some picks that will not amount to anything and...

Taro T Hall of Famer

Taro T

Posted
Posted

AND the condition is the Sharks re-signing him, not lottery.  THIS SUX!

 

John Vogl Retweeted

 

lebrun_twitter_49669_bigger.jpgPierre LeBrun‏Verified account @PierreVLeBrun 37s38 seconds ago

 

 

More

 

 

 

 

Here's the condition of the first-round 2019 pick in the Evander Kane deal: if the Sharks re-sign Kane, it's a first; but if Kane walks into free agency, it's a second-round pick in 2019

 

 

So, then, wtf is the condition on the 2020 4th (or were early reports that was also conditional misreported)?

 

So, at the end of the day, it looks like the Sabres get $5.25MM in cap space next year, 2 sticks & a skate sharpener. Awesome. (Where's the shaking your head emoji when you really need it.) <_<

Randall Flagg Hall of Famer

Randall Flagg

Posted
Posted

This could go down as the worst trade in Sabres history. That 2nd rd pick in 2019 better turn out to be a great player.

No, it couldn't. A rental on an expiring contract will never even exist in these conversations. 

SDS All Star

SDS

Posted
Posted

You said only GMs opinions matter in a thread where we are specifically sharing our opinion on something

 

That is in response to fans saying he is worth more. 31 GMs disagreed. That point is neither wrong, nor does it say to stop talking about it.

Gramps Fourth Liner

Gramps

Posted
Posted

There was no better offer over the last year than this?

 

I have no idea and am willing to wait for GMJB's presser. Maybe Kane is the locker room cancer ? 

Derrico First Liner

Derrico

Posted
Posted

Come on GA. Worst trade in franchise history?! LMAO. We're trading a rental player. One with a very checkered history. There's no evidence out there that there was ever a better deal on the table. To me this is still better than getting absolutely nothing. Still not thrilled with the return but it is what it is.

Gramps Fourth Liner

Gramps

Posted
Posted

Half the teams in the NHL probably don't want anything to do with him due to his attitude/reputation/off ice stuff whether its fair or not...when you are limiting the number of potential suitors you are also limiting his worth

 

Winner winner chicken dinner !

nfreeman Hall of Famer

nfreeman

Posted
Posted

I will be interested to see how Kane does in FA.  If he doesn't get a fat long-term deal, it will support the position that his value today wasn't very high.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...