Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

^

 

I really don't think an argument can be made that any single current NHL player means more to their team than Jack Eichel means to the Buffalo Sabres. Not talking just on-ice production wise.

Posted

^

I really don't think an argument can be made that any single current NHL player means more to their team than Jack Eichel means to the Buffalo Sabres. Not talking just on-ice production wise.

McJesus means more to the Oilers. In all ways possible.

Posted (edited)

McJesus means more to the Oilers. In all ways possible.

Disagree completely. Eichel represents just as much to the Sabres fan base as McDavid does to that of the Oilers. Maybe moreso, as we are entrusting our hopes of a FIRST cup to him.

 

Sabres rely on Eichel, on the ice, as much as the Oil rely on McDavid.

Edited by Thorny
Posted

Disagree completely. Eichel represents just as much to the Sabres fan base as McDavid does. Maybe moreso, as we are entrusting our hopes of a FIRST cup to him.

Sabres rely on Eichel, on the ice, as much or moreso than the Oil rely on McDavid.

I most wholeheartedly disagree. The Oilers had literally half a generation of high end draft picks float through their franchise. Nothing stuck. The best player in quite some time, indeed, since well before the Oilers were bad enough to keep drafting first, and things go up from there. It should take nothing more than a short clip of the tears dude fought so hard to keep in when Edmonton won the lottery to know that they lucked ass-backwards into one of the greatest players ever. Dunno how dJack beats that, at least for the fans. And yes I assume all fans, as humans, are terrible monsters.

Posted (edited)

I most wholeheartedly disagree. The Oilers had literally half a generation of high end draft picks float through their franchise. Nothing stuck. The best player in quite some time, indeed, since well before the Oilers were bad enough to keep drafting first, and things go up from there. It should take nothing more than a short clip of the tears dude fought so hard to keep in when Edmonton won the lottery to know that they lucked ass-backwards into one of the greatest players ever. Dunno how dJack beats that, at least for the fans. And yes I assume all fans, as humans, are terrible monsters.

I dunno...I know McDavid is a better player. But, Aaron Rodgers is better than Andrew Luck, too. But yet the Packers rely on Rodgers no more than the Colts rely on Luck.

 

The Sabres also waited longer for their "generational skater" than the Oilers did.

 

Perreault has been gone longer than Gretzky and Messier have been.

 

Still think Eichel means as much to the Sabres as any player does to their team. That just my view.

Edited by Thorny
Posted

I think Edmonton is still a bottom 5 team without McDavid, and this season they'll be a President's Trophy contender. Eichel doesn't definitively bring up possession and goals-for-percentage stats for his teammates yet, let alone impact wins/losses (I believe we had the same win percentage with him as without him this year)

Posted

I think Edmonton is still a bottom 5 team without McDavid, and this season they'll be a President's Trophy contender. Eichel doesn't definitively bring up possession and goals-for-percentage stats for his teammates yet, let alone impact wins/losses (I believe we had the same win percentage with him as without him this year)

We have no idea if this is true. Bylsma was abysmal at coaching anything resembling a possession brand of hockey. 

Posted

I think Edmonton is still a bottom 5 team without McDavid, and this season they'll be a President's Trophy contender. Eichel doesn't definitively bring up possession and goals-for-percentage stats for his teammates yet, let alone impact wins/losses (I believe we had the same win percentage with him as without him this year)

We have no idea if this is true. Bylsma was abysmal at coaching anything resembling a possession brand of hockey. 

Pretty sure there are stats on this somewhere. 

Posted

I think Edmonton is still a bottom 5 team without McDavid, and this season they'll be a President's Trophy contender. Eichel doesn't definitively bring up possession and goals-for-percentage stats for his teammates yet, let alone impact wins/losses (I believe we had the same win percentage with him as without him this year)

And the Oilers had a better record post McDavid injury than they did pre-McDavid injury, in his first season.

 

There are lots of different variables and factors that went into the teams' winning percentage with/without Eichel, (and McDavid). I'll attempt to express the view again that I not talking about raw stats.

 

I'm talking about what Eichel means to the psyche of Sabres fans, on a broad scale. In my view, there is no way that we value what Eichel means for the Sabres less than what McDavid means to Oilers fans. The burden of value placed upon an athelete beloved by a fan base can't be simply broken down into an equation, or statistics.

 

If one were to somehow able to create a list of which players their respective fan bases held in highest regard, it wouldn't correspond precisely to a list of talent and production, top to bottom.

 

I find it hard to believe that Eichel means less to Sabres fans than McDavid does to Oilers fans. I guarantee Auston Matthews means as much to Leafs fans as McDavid does to Oilers fans. Unless I'm sorely mistaken in how much Eichel means to Sabres fans. And that wouldn't be an encouraging thought.

Posted

Pretty sure there are stats on this somewhere. 

Bylsma sucking at coaching hockey? We do, it is called Pittsburgh's 2 Stanley Cups and Buffalo's 2 lackluster seasons with bottom league possession stats.

Posted

And the Oilers had a better record post McDavid injury than they did pre-McDavid injury, in his first season.

There are lots of different variables and factors that went into the teams' winning percentage with/without Eichel, (and McDavid). I'll attempt to express the view again that I not talking about raw stats.

I'm talking about what Eichel means to the psyche of Sabres fans, on a broad scale. In my view, there is no way that we value what Eichel means for the Sabres less than what McDavid means to Oilers fans. The burden of value placed upon an athelete beloved by a fan base can't be simply broken down into an equation, or statistics.

If one were to somehow able to create a list of which players their respective fan bases held in highest regard, it wouldn't correspond precisely to a list of talent and production, top to bottom.

I find it hard to believe that Eichel means less to Sabres fans than McDavid does to Oilers fans. I guarantee Auston Matthews means as much to Leafs fans as McDavid does to Oilers fans. Unless I'm sorely mistaken in how much Eichel means to Sabres fans. And that wouldn't be an encouraging thought.

I think you're underestimating the desperation of those fanbases as compared to ours.

Posted

How could Edmonton be a more desperate fan base? Sabres have had way less success. The only time we were good in the last 15 years, the Oilers went to the final.

Before McDavid they were the laughingstock of the league for about 10 years straight.
Posted

Ya. We are too.

 

We haven't won a playoff series in over a decade.

Won a playoff series... Yes that is what use to happen. Won with Drury and Briere... Now we have Eichel and he comes to us at the turn of the tide.
This topic is OLD. A NEW topic should be started unless there is a VERY SPECIFIC REASON to revive this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...