Jump to content

Suspend Crosby  

41 members have voted

  1. 1. Should NHL suspend crosby

    • Yes
      32
    • No
      6


Recommended Posts

Posted

Yea, givin' the attack on O'Reilly the game before and the rule ok slashing clearly stating if the slash results in injury it is an automatic 5 and game misconduct, a couple game suspension is in order.

 

Sid's out of control lol

Posted

I voted no. It won't happen, and I will spend zero time thinking about it, because me thinking about it won't change anything.

 

 

Yada Yada Yada purpose of discussion blah blah Crosby.

Posted

I had been unaware of his shot on O'Reilly. I'd bet dollars to donuts that's payback for something. It doesn't overly concern me.

 

As for the finger chop, I don't think a suspension is really warranted. How many times do players get slashed on the hands every night? Dozens of times? It certainly seems like it happens all the time. This outcome seems like a freakish, unlikely one. Or is it the case that Crosby is an elite hand-slasher, just like he is with just about every other thing he does on the ice?

Posted (edited)

I voted No... It seems to me that both the crotch spear and the mild slash are fairly routine plays.

so, getting speared in the balls and getting your finger tip chopped off are ok with you?

 

how come no one goes after him?

Edited by nucci
Posted

I had been unaware of his shot on O'Reilly. I'd bet dollars to donuts that's payback for something. It doesn't overly concern me.

 

As for the finger chop, I don't think a suspension is really warranted. How many times do players get slashed on the hands every night? Dozens of times? It certainly seems like it happens all the time. This outcome seems like a freakish, unlikely one. Or is it the case that Crosby is an elite hand-slasher, just like he is with just about every other thing he does on the ice?

How wouldnt he be.... though Kane got him back.... old toothless.

Posted

I have played hockey for a ton of years, and watched too and not often you see anything close to Methot's injury...Cindy is getting worse as he finds that he is getting away with this **it...he will get even worse too unless the NHL does something to send a massage and stop him (which they won't do to him in a million years)

Posted (edited)

so, getting speared in the balls and getting your finger tip chopped off are ok with you?

No I'm not "ok with" those two things, but I don't think either warrants a suspension.

 

As other posters have said, players get their hands slashed with that same, mild amount of malice every night.  The fact that it was a freak thing shouldn't warrant a suspension.

 

I'm also not "ok with" getting face-washed, or cross-checked, or slashed in the arms or legs.  But none of those things warrants a suspension.

 

Edit: I should say that, it seems to me these two incidents both warrant penalties, although I can understand that a ref would miss the sneaky little crotch-spear.

Edited by Cereal
Posted

We KNOW that was payback.

Interesting comment from a Deadspin commenter saying: After Tuesday night’s brutal dick-shot to Ryan O’Reilly, he wouldn’t even come out of the dressing room to meet with his family and friends. They were escorted back to meet him, which... is not how that usually works. So, he has some sense of shame.

 

I wonder if there's truth to it?

Posted

Interesting comment from a Deadspin commenter saying: After Tuesday night’s brutal dick-shot to Ryan O’Reilly, he wouldn’t even come out of the dressing room to meet with his family and friends. They were escorted back to meet him, which... is not how that usually works. So, he has some sense of shame.[/size]

 

I wonder if there's truth to it?[/size]

Good PR but didnt last long... Methot's finger...

Posted

Good PR but didnt last long... Methot's finger...

Yes but, I can't believe i'm sort of defending crosby, the guy doesn't have some laser accuracy to swing his stick across a players body and perfectly chop his finger around the glove padding. that's just bad luck. guys slash sticks all the time without this result. 

Posted

He should've received 2 minutes for preventing Cal O'Reilly from ever knowing the joy of unclehood.

 

He should've received a 5 & a game for the play that will keep Methot from ever getting to hold a tea cup the British way again.

 

Neither he nor Ristolainen should have received a suspension for their acts the past few nights.

Posted

I will never understand the way that this league is ran. It's as if their sole focus is on increasing the fan base even if it means alienating their existing base. The preferential treatment of original six teams, big market teams, all stars etc. People who love hockey already do, no point in always trying to become larger while aggravating your bread and butter.

This topic is OLD. A NEW topic should be started unless there is a VERY SPECIFIC REASON to revive this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...