Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

There is a reason that scouts tag some draftable QBs with size warnings even though there are anomalies like Wilson and Brees. And I do agree that tall QBs also move around at times to see the field better but the extra few inches does matter - would Brady be as good at 6'0" ? 

 

Would you rather have a John Elway/Brett Favre/Peyton Manning/Jim Kelly type as your franchise QB or someone 6'1" on paper and most likely shorter ? 

Would you rather have a Brock Osweiler/Joe Flacco/Nick Foles/Blake Bortles type as your franchise QB or someone who can actually play? Your post makes it sound like all great QBs are tall, or all tall Qbs are great. That's not true, those are the top 5 tallest QBs in the league today

Posted

Would you rather have a Brock Osweiler/Joe Flacco/Nick Foles/Blake Bortles type as your franchise QB or someone who can actually play? Your post makes it sound like all great QBs are tall, or all tall Qbs are great. That's not true, those are the top 5 tallest QBs in the league today

 

There was a reason I used those guys and not the ones you mentioned with the exception of Flacco. I actually think he can play a bit. 

 

All other things being equal, I'll take someone 6'2" and above. 

Posted (edited)

As long as we're not talking about someone who is 5'2", nobody should care about an inch here or there. This isn't penis size.

There was a reason I used those guys and not the ones you mentioned with the exception of Flacco. I actually think he can play a bit.

 

All other things being equal, I'll take someone 6'2" and above.

But how often are things equal outside of height? Basically never. Edited by TrueBlueGED
Posted (edited)

As long as we're not talking about someone who is 5'2", nobody should care about an inch here or there. This isn't penis size.

But how often are things equal outside of height? Basically never.

 

With the notable exception of Brees, all of the top 15 in career passing yards are 6'2" and taller. Brady has won 5, mostly passing from the pocket and with limited mobility. Draft a taller guy with a great arm, build an offensive line to protect him, and get him some weapons.

Edited by gramps
Posted (edited)

With the notable exception of Brees, all of the top 15 in career passing yards are 6'2" and taller. Brady has won 5, mostly passing from the pocket and with limited mobility. Draft a taller guy with a great arm, build an offensive line to protect him, and get him some weapons.

So you'll take Josh Allen over Baker Mayfield? A drastic example I know, but I think smaller guys can succeed, there's just not a lot of smaller players who play QB

Edited by WildCard
Posted (edited)

So you'll take Josh Allen over Baker Mayfield? A drastic example I know, but I think smaller guys can succeed, there's just not a lot of smaller players who play QB

 

Some say Mayfield's arm strength is average at best, so maybe I look harder at Allen/Rosen/Darnold/Jackson. Mayfield also played on a lot better team than Allen. 

 

And you are right, some smaller guys can succeed if the offense is built to their strong points a la Wilson.

Edited by gramps
Posted

If that causes Mayfield to fall to the Bills, it's all good. ;)

The guy threw for less than 100 yards SEVERAL TIMES!!! In the mountain west!!

 

But I take your point.

Posted

The guy threw for less than 100 yards SEVERAL TIMES!!! In the mountain west!!

 

But I take your point.

 

Maybe he had no one to throw to ... kinda like Tyrod.

Posted

Tyrod has sucked no matter the coach or talent around him

 

Nope.  He's been average.  But average isn't enough on this team--or most.  

Posted

Nope.  He's been average.  But average isn't enough on this team--or most.  

 

Glad you said most as Trent Dilfer was pretty average.

When has that ever stopped anyone in college?

 

I'm giving him the doubt of the benefit - hurt his throwing shoulder against Air Force.

Posted

I'm giving him the doubt of the benefit - hurt his throwing shoulder against Air Force.

I can't give him anything. He's playing in the Mountain West and was being discussed as a potential #1 pick. He should throw for 700 yards every game.

Posted (edited)

Glad you said most as Trent Dilfer was pretty average.

 

 

I'm giving him the doubt of the benefit - hurt his throwing shoulder against Air Force.

Allen has been bad all year. I'd rather take 5 other qbs b4 him. Would be like drafting ej Manuel in the first, stupid.

I can't give him anything. He's playing in the Mountain West and was being discussed as a potential #1 pick. He should throw for 700 yards every game.

Exactly. He's not playing Clemson or Auburn or Georgia. He plays teams no one knows with mediocre defense. Edited by LGR4GM
Posted

Allen has been bad all year. I'd rather take 5 other qbs b4 him. Would be like drafting ej Manuel in the first, stupid.

Exactly. He's not playing Clemson or Auburn or Georgia. He plays teams no one knows with mediocre defense.

 

You mean like Carson Wentz ? 

Posted

Not sure if you are being facetious but he could have easily given him a neck injury (don't know if he didn't actually) and he Did give him a brain injury. It wasn't during play or some type of football move. It was assault. He drove his elbow, a 270 lbs man running and jumping, into the base of his skull. If TRE was my kid, I'd hunt down gronk and give him some justice. It was filthy and criminal.

You complete me ...

Posted (edited)

If you didn't see it, the Steelers-Bengals game was violent tonight. Perfect football

 

Bell steamrolls

https://twitter.com/NFL/status/937897329125818369/video/1

 

Burfict gets destroyed on a block by JuJu

https://twitter.com/_TailgateSports/status/937901657777688576/video/1

 

Brown dies and still gets the TD

https://twitter.com/NFL/status/937905200970350592/video/1

Edited by WildCard
Posted (edited)

FWIW.

 

Pregame worship service to take place before Bills meet Dolphins

 

Faithful who are also football fans have an invitation from organizers to gather from 9:45 to 10:45 a.m. in the Ad Pro Sports Training Center, adjacent to the Bills stadium, for a nondenominational Christian service.

 

http://buffalonews.com/2017/12/04/pregame-worship-service-to-take-place-before-bills-meet-dolphins/

 

+++

 

I've chirped plenty about this influence at OBD, but, in fairness, if the franchise finds its surrounding environs becoming known as a sort of modern Sodom and Gomorrah, it's probably appropriate to introduce some vibes on the other side of the ledger. 

Edited by That Aud Smell
Posted

You mean like Carson Wentz ? 

But is Wentz the exception or the rule?  Also Wentz never tossed 15 interceptions. He only threw 14 his entire college career if what I see is correct.  I am just saying Allen doesn't pass the eye test at all and I would be hesitant to draft him in the first round. Just because you need a QB doesn't mean the one you target is a first round QB.  The Bills need to be smart. I question Allen's decision making. 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...