Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

In light of the discussion in the awesome thread and my desire to see this thread get more traffic, I'm changing the title to The Music Thread.

 

So long as Eleven and his heresy/trolling about The Beatles is banned herefrom, I'll contribute.

Posted

So long as Eleven and his heresy/trolling about The Beatles is banned herefrom, I'll contribute.

 

The Beatles are totally a boy band.

 

And I say that as someone who really likes The Beatles. 

Posted

Boy bands are Svengali'd. John and Paul met at a church fete.

 

Boy bands perform music written for them by others. Lennon and McCartney are two of the more accomplished songwriters of the 20th century, and as a team, probably unrivaled.

 

I could go on. Maybe later I will.

 

This is nonsensical hottakery of the highest order.

Posted

Also, I think this thread should be locked because it has become so deeply offensive.

:lol: 

 

Listen, I'm not saying The Beatles weren't artists. But there are plenty of boy band members who are great artists too. JT anyone?

 

The Beatles started the whole idea of marketing "heart throbs" to teenagers. No one had ever marketed music to teens before. They paved the way for the boy bands and record label money grabs of the late 90's. It's all The Beatles' fault. 

Posted

Boy bands are Svengali'd. John and Paul met at a church fete.

 

Boy bands perform music written for them by others. Lennon and McCartney are two of the more accomplished songwriters of the 20th century, and as a team, probably unrivaled.

 

I could go on. Maybe later I will.

 

This is nonsensical hottakery of the highest order.

This.

 

Boy bands are assembled. The Beatles were discovered. There is a difference.

 

The Monkeys were a boy band.

 

:lol: 

 

Listen, I'm not saying The Beatles weren't artists. But there are plenty of boy band members who are great artists too. JT anyone?

 

The Beatles started the whole idea of marketing "heart throbs" to teenagers. No one had ever marketed music to teens before. They paved the way for the boy bands and record label money grabs of the late 90's. It's all The Beatles' fault. 

Yeah. No one ever did that before the Beatles.

post-1429-0-90009700-1475717506_thumb.jpg

Posted

Listen, I'm not saying The Beatles weren't artists. But there are plenty of boy band members who are great artists too. JT anyone.

Well thank God for confirmation that The Beatles were artists.

 

And please don't ever put Timberlake in the same breath (or belch) as The Beatles. And I like Timberlake just fine.

Posted

The Beatles started the whole idea of marketing "heart throbs" to teenagers. No one had ever marketed music to teens before. They paved the way for the boy bands and record label money grabs of the late 90's. It's all The Beatles' fault.

The marketing of The Beatles had plenty of predecessors that foretold their arrival -- John the Baptists, if you will.

 

And The Beatles weren't the first in a line of such bands. They were, are an entity and phenomenon unto themselves. Sui generis.

 

I think I'm more aggravated and disappointed by The Beatles as boy band talk than I could be by anything in the politics thread.

Elvis is a whole different animal. Is there any doubt The Beatles were more commercialized than him?

What?! This is madness.

Posted

The marketing of The Beatles had plenty of predecessors that foretold their arrival -- John the Baptists, if you will.

 

And The Beatles weren't the first in a line of such bands. They were, are an entity and phenomenon unto themselves. Sui generis.

 

I think I'm more aggravated and disappointed by The Beatles as boy band talk than I could be by anything in the politics thread.

 

What?! This is madness.

 

I know. I'm just arguing it to be annoying. 

 

I actually don't care either way.  :P

Posted

I know. I'm just arguing it to be annoying. 

 

I actually don't care either way.  :P

If that's your way of admitting you were wrong, then we accept your apology.  :P right back atcha.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...