It just seems to me that in many ways the Tuch negotiations are a crucial test of the seriousness of this organization. I know many would argue that question is already answered and I would not dispute that sentiment, but to the extent hope remains then this negotiation is critical.
I do not see any way the Sabres can let Tuch walk and have any prayer of fielding a competitive team with this current regime or player set. Quite simply, he embodies what they have been preaching they want in their players, in every respect. I care little about league comparison of value based on advanced stats or any other measure when discussing Tuch. He is critical to THIS team. Signing him provides a window for this team to right this particular ship and move forward. Failure to sign him is admission of failure, and whether they would admit it or not, a restart on the rebuild yet again.