Live in the Rochester area now. Haven't had Carbones in Rochester yet but nothing comes remotely close to Buffalo pizza. My sons (11 YO and 8 YO) even notice the difference and like Buffalo pizza better.
Guidas and Clemenzas are the best in the area. Marks, Salvatores, Perri's, Pontillos are so generic.
Just looked at the list...Authentic Detroit style is underrated, still not as good as Buffalo!